What is the best kind of gas detector to use in confined spaces?
I work on a construction site and frequently enter vessels and other types of confined spaces. It seems like there are too many options when it comes to monitors. What is the best kind of gas detector to use in confined spaces?
It can only take seconds to succumb to a hazardous atmosphere in a confined space. That’s why investing in high quality gas detectors is one of the most important steps you can take to protect workers. But selecting the appropriate monitor for a confined space isn’t a piece of cake; it depends on the space being entered and the type of work being performed.
Unfortunately, there is no one type of gas detector I can recommend to fit every situation. You need to carefully review the needs of your workers and pick the best detector for your confined space (learn more in Working in Confined Spaces? You Need the Right Training).
With a wide variety of products to choose from, let’s take a look at the features you must consider when selecting a gas detector for used in confined spaces.
You must know what you need to measure before you can decide on a detector. If you don’t have an idea of the risks your workers face, it’s time to conduct a hazard assessment.
The types of sensors on your chosen detector should reflect the known and possible atmospheric hazards posed by the confined space it will be used in. Every confined space gas detector must, at the very least, have Hydrgen Sulfide (H2S), Lower Explosive Limit (LEL), Carbon Monoxide (CO), and Oxygen (O2) sensors.
For confined spaces where a specific gas is common, you may want to consider substance-specific sensors. These are available for a wide range of gases including:
- Sulfur dioxide
- Nitrogen dioxide
For confined spaces where contaminants can vary widely (for example, in sewers), using both a chemosorption (MOS) sensor that responds to a wide range of contaminants and several substance-specific sensors may be the safest approach.
Most instruments are classified for intrinsic safety. This means that their design prevents the possibility of ignition. While many devices are certified for use in Class I hazardous locations, some confined spaces require devices carry the classification for use in Class II locations, as well. Class II groups refer to “combustible dusts” and may be necessary for applications like in grain silos.
Ease of Operation
If a device is too complicated for a worker to easily use, it will likely be neglected. Gas detectors should be simple and straightforward. Confined spaces often have little room to maneuver in, so it’s critical that workers can use the device without adjusting settings or trying to figure out how to use complex features.
Confined spaces can be dark and noisy, so it’s essential that gas detector alarms be sufficient to get the attention of the user – this means loud and highly visible. Look for buzzers, flashing lights, explanatory messages, and built-in vibrator alarms.
Taking the above factors into consideration, infrared sensors are often a good choice for use in confined spaces. These instruments consist of a gas cell through which infrared radiation passes, thereby allowing an atmosphere to be tested somewhat remotely. Since infrared sensors cannot detect hydrogen, some applications may necessitate the use of a catalytic sensor as well.
I highly recommend trying a device prior to purchase. While performance information and feature descriptions are helpful, nothing truly replaces trying a gas detector out under similar conditions to the ones where it will be used.
More Q&As from our experts
- What types of gas should I watch out for when working in a confined space?
- How can employers prepare for OSHA's final rule?
- Are earplugs always better than earmuffs?