10 Reasons to Contest an OSHA Citation
Not every OSHA citation is worth contesting, but you might want to consider it if any of these 10 reasons apply to you.
In 2017, there were 32,396 federal OSHA inspections and another 43,551 inspections performed by state OSHA inspectors (see 12 Things to Do During an OSHA Investigation for advice on navigating these).
If you were one of the lucky businesses visited by OSHA and they found issues in your place of business, you probably received a citation. If you have already received an OSHA visit in 2018, you may be waiting to hear from OSHA, who has up to six months (from the start of the inspection) to issue a citation. Once a citation arrives, you have 15 days to act on it.
If you receive a citation, how would you handle it?
The Cost of an OSHA Citation
With a 2018 maximum penalty for either a Serious or Other-than-Serious Violation set at $12,934 (per citation), many companies will make an informal appeal to receive a reduction and then make long-term payments on the citation. This is typically because the cost of legal fees far outweigh the cost of the penalty.
While $12,934 is manageable, that is the amount per violation. It doesn’t take much to run up a $50,000 penalty for multiple violations.
Minor things like forgetting to use a seatbelt on a forklift, not using the right description on an OSHA 300 log, or using an extension cord for a permanent application instead of temporary application can all result in citations that cause an employer to lawyer up.
Employers cited for Willful Violations face penalties ten times higher. These are violations where OSHA believes the employer knew what it was supposed to do but made a conscious decision not to, and they come with a cost of $129,336 per violation.
The penalty for Repeated Violations is the same: $129,336 per violation.
For those of you with multiple locations, Repeat Violations are considered across the entire organization.
To make matters worse, what used to be a three-year look into the past for Repeat Violations changed to five years in 2016 and in February of this year, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that there is no statutory limitation on Repeat Violations.
Your Options for Dealing with a Citation
So how do you handle this?
When it comes to citations, you have three choices:
- Accept the citation as written and pay the penalty
- Arrange for an informal conference with OSHA in hopes of reducing the penalty amount
- Contest the citation
Believe it or not, not every OSHA citation is worth contesting. Often, the correct decision is to accept the citation or reach a settlement with OSHA at the informal conference. However, when costs start to add up, contesting may be the best decision for your company.
Safety Plus, Inc’s Ten Reasons to Contest an OSHA Citation
How do you know when to fight a fine instead of just paying it? Here are ten scenarios in which you might want to contest your OSHA citation.
1. No Violation Occurred
OSHA generally has the burden of proving that a violation occurred. If this burden cannot be met, or the evidence shows that no violation occurred, then contesting the violation is recommended.
2. Wrong Category of Violation Cited
OSHA has a higher burden of proof citing a Willful Violation than for a Serious or Other-than-serious Violation. If the proof cannot be met for the category cited, you have a good chance of at least drastically reducing the cost of the Citation. Remember, a Willful Violation ($129,336) is ten times more expensive than a Serious Violation ($12,934).
3. Availability of Positive Defense
There are certain procedural and substantive defenses required to overturn OSHA violations. The burden of proving a defense lies with the employer. If this burden can be met for the cited violation, think about contesting.
4. Proposed Penalty Amount Is Significant
Where the cost of the citation becomes too burdensome, the financial stakes may be too high to not consider contesting the citation.
5. Costly Abatement
Where the citation mandates a costly abatement, or an abatement which requires business disruption, think about contesting.
6. Settlement Options
It may be worth going through the Informal Settlement and if the result is not acceptable, think about contesting the citations.
If an Informal Settlement is not a viable option before the applicable deadline, contesting the citations may be necessary to preserve settlement as an option further down the line.
7. Risk of Repeat OSHA Citations
Previous citations can be cited by OSHA as a basis for later Willful or Repeat Violations. If a citation places an employer in OSHA’s Severe Violator Program, it increases the frequency of inspections. The risk of future OSHA inspections and citations can be a reason to think about a Notice of Contest.
8. Future Potential Civil Liability
State laws vary significantly, but some jurisdictions allow OSHA citations to be considered in personal injury litigation. The admissibility and relevance of the OSHA citation may help you to decide to contest it.
9. Industry Reputation
For many businesses, a reputation for safety in the workplace is an asset worth fighting to protect. An OSHA citation may be the basis for the loss of ongoing business, loss in reputation, or the loss of future business relationships. Inclusion in OSHA’s Severe Violator Enforcement Program can be especially damaging. For reputation alone, a Notice of Contest may be worthwhile (find out How to Look After Your Business' Safety Reputation).
10. Increased Worker’s Compensation Insurance Premiums
Several states have statutes that authorize an increase in workers’ compensation insurance premiums based on safety and health violations. To keep your insurance costs reasonable, you could contest an OSHA citation.
A surprise visit from OSHA can be costly, but knowing when to contest violations can significantly reduce the amount your company pays after the visit. For more information, check out Safety Plus, Inc’s Webinar: “Managing Unexpected OSHA Visits, Part 3: What to do after the OSHA inspection.”
More from Safety Plus Inc.
- How often should our organization hold safety meetings?
- What is the best way to integrate safety data across multiple platforms?
- How do we organize and conduct an initial safety audit of our facility if we don't have a Certified Safety Professional on staff?
- Should the risk of future, repeat OSHA citations figure into my company’s decision to contest a citation?
- What are my rights when an OSHA inspector comes to my workplace?
- What can I do to deal with unexpected OSHA inspections?
- Reimagining Contractor Qualification: Questions Answered